skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Kathryn Norlock at St. Mary’s College of Maryland has produced a study enumerating the articles which philosophy journals have published on the topic of feminism. This sort of empirical accounting for the status of women in philosophy is essential but too often neglected. So thanks, Kathryn, for collating and analyzing this information!
Dr. Norlock’s preface and summary results of feminism-publishing journals follow:
The following lists are entirely compiled from Philosophers’ Index, and therefore are not representative of all journals available, only those listing with the Index, and of course, the Index itself is not complete. However, they may be useful to those wondering what journals on the index report. These are intended as suggestive only, since the methodology only searched for articles specifically described as feminist in approach. New and student scholars were especially interested to know the recent rough history of Index-listing journals.
Methodology: JN (journal name) and femini* in DE (descriptor) were initially searched for repeated journals. On subsequent searches, individual journal names were searched for femini* in DE (descriptor). Cross-checking yielded clear leaders, though the results are, as said, limited by the self-reporting nature of the Index.
The first number is the total number of articles, the second is the number since (and including) 2000. Journals who only had listings since 2000 have just one number, the total number of feminism-described articles, followed by the earliest year's article in parentheses.
PHILOSOPHER'S INDEX results:
Top 12, Highest to lowest, feminist-described, since/including 2000:
Hypatia 513/152
Social Epistemology 23/15
Philosophy Today 25/12
Constellations 18/10
Philosophy of Science 10/9
Feminist Studies 69/8
Journal of Social Philosophy 54/8
Radical Philosophy, 36/8
Journal of Speculative Philosophy 13/8
Bioethics 12/8
Theory, Culture and Society 9/8
Nursing Philosophy 8 (2000)
These are only part of Dr. Norlock’s results. The remainder can be found by joining the Google Group called “Feminist Draft Exchange” at this URL:
http://groups.google.com/group/feministdraftexchange/web/feminism-publishing-journals
I have some thoughts on these results.
First, it is incredibly helpful to young (i.e. untenured) scholars to know the recent history for feminism-friendly philosophy journals. There has been some recent discussion about whether there is bias against women among philosophy journals (and, especially, bias against publishing feminism). Ethics has published only 7 articles since 2000 (and none since 2002) using the keyword “feminism.” It's entirely possible that the journal has not received many submissions, but if my tenure were on the line and I was working in a finite time-frame, I don’t think I would take that chance.
Second, for more on the issue of publishing feminist theory, I recommend Sally Haslanger’s paper(pdf) that has been making the rounds and is soon to be published in Hypatia. Her recommendations for taking action to improve the climate for women in philosophy include this:
Established feminists should:
• Submit work to mainstream journals.
• Use the term ‘feminism’/’feminist’ in our writing.
• Cite feminist work; urge mainstream colleagues to read and reference feminist work in
their areas.
Third, it would be worth refining Norlock’s results, a difficult task given the limitations of the Philosopher’s Index. I’ve noticed one discrepancy. Having posted here before on the difficult climate for women in philosophy of science, I was surprised (stunned, actually!) to see that Philosophy of Science was ranked among the top 5 journals for publishing feminist theory. I took a look at the ten articles that Norlock counted (using the methods that she helpfully provided), and six of them are in the annual supplement to the journal which contains Proceedings of the PSA conference (until recently conference papers were published under a separate title). So only two of the ten articles appear to be peer-reviewed. One is Janet Kourany’s paper “A Philosophy of Science for the Twenty-first Century” (2003), which was published with a response by Ron Giere and a reply by the author. The other is a 1994 article by Cassandra Pinnick dismissing the legitimacy of feminist philosophy of science.
There has been earlier discussion of feminist publishing in philosophy over at Feminist Philosophers and at the Lemmings Blog.
In the last few weeks, philosophy bloggers have posted their various evaluations of the European Science Foundation's journal rankings. For a partial list of the journals and bloggers' comments, see Leiter Reports, Lemmings, Feminist Philosophers, Gone Public, and Brooks Blog.
Although analytic philosophers seem to be mostly satisfied with the list as a rough cut, continental and feminist philosophers have raised some concerns that it reinforces a popular but not universally accepted standard for what counts as the best philosophical writing.
John McCumber has made several important points:
1. that the European Science Foundation has a questionable agenda in ranking journals in the humanities.
2. that simple rankings invite mis-use by tenure committees looking for easy to make and easy to enforce judgments about research quality.
3. that although the list's purpose may be in part to promote rigorous (blind) peer review, not all the journals in the A-List are peer-reviewed in the standard way.
4. that the list is based on journals' "reputations" but it does not say how those reputations have been evaluated. Indeed, McCumber points out that the analytic focus of the A-Listed journals coincides with the analytic research interests of the committee that compiled the list.
There are a number of reasons to be wary of ANY simple ranking scheme.
1. Lists serve the status quo.
Any list is bound to favor older, well-established journals that publish papers across a range of areas in philosophy. These journals have well-earned reputations. But they are less likely to publish philosophical papers that attempt to push philosophy in new directions—that are multi- or cross-disciplinary, that challenge analytic methods and styles, that deepen newer paradigms, such as environmental and feminist frameworks, or that apply philosophy to solving practical problems, as in medical ethics. Most specialty journals--and all specialty journals that are not analytic--are classified as B-List. But the criterion that journals not specialize does not speak to the quality of the papers they publish.
2. Many of the journals on the list are not double-blind reviewed, and as McCumber points out, a decision of whether or not to publish a paper
needs to be blind, and preferably double blind. The way major philosophy journals are editorially reviewed in this country simply reinforces the dominance of the old over the young, and is I think a major reason why there are so few new ideas in American philosophy compared to other disciplines.
3. Lists can serve the interests of administrators looking to deny tenure, but cannot so easily be used in the interests of younger members of the profession. It is not helpful as a guide to where to submit papers because it does not reflect considerations such as acceptance rates, moratoriums, the time it takes to get a response from the journal, reputations within particular sub-disciplines of philosophy, and citation rates.
Indeed, it is not clear why this or any other list would be superior to a simple citation ranking as is used in the sciences (though even that type of ranking is subject to all the above faults and is too often mis-used).
My final thought about journals is a question raised by my friend Jim Johnson, who asked why the prominent philosophy journals are not published by professional organizations. And I don’t know the answer. In political science, two prominent journals are published by professional organizations. This is also common in the sciences, where both the general interest journals (like Science) and specialty journals (like Ecology) are published by organizations (AAAS and ESA, respectively). When journals are published by organizations, then they have a tighter connection with the organization’s membership and a direct duty to be responsive to the profession, and particularly to the young members of the profession. (Although no doubt this accountability causes head-aches for journal editors!)